Health score
0
/ 100Verdict: moderate
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner earns a moderate score of 65/100 due to its use of synthetic polymers and preservatives alongside skin-friendly humectants.
Key takeaways
- Features synthetic mica for shimmer
- Contains hydrating glycerin for skin comfort
- Uses phenoxyethanol as a preservative
- Long-wear formula via acrylates copolymer
- Packaging is difficult to recycle
Our read on this product
This eyeliner relies on Synthetic Fluorphlogopite to provide its signature shimmer, offering a safer profile than traditional mineral-based micas. The inclusion of Glycerin helps keep the formula from cracking, earning points for skin-moisture maintenance. However, the use of Acrylates Copolymer and Phenoxyethanol limits the overall health score to 65/100. While these ingredients are standard in long-wear cosmetics, they lack the natural benefits that would push this into the healthy category. Environmentally, the product scores a 40/100, largely due to the difficulty of recycling its small plastic components.
Best for
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner is suitable for individuals looking for a long-lasting, shimmery eyeliner that is easy to apply.
Approach with care
Those with known sensitivities to phenoxyethanol or individuals prioritizing plastic-free, highly recyclable cosmetic packaging should avoid this product.
Ingredient breakdown
Good ingredients
Neutral ingredients
Aqua (Water)
Used as a solvent and base for the formula. It helps to dissolve other ingredients and create the desired consistency for application.
Synthetic Fluorphlogopite
A synthetic mica used to provide shimmer, sparkle, and pigment effect. It is generally considered a safer, more consistent alternative to natural mica.
Acrylates Copolymer
Film-forming agents that help the eyeliner adhere to the skin and resist smudging. These are synthetic polymers widely used in long-wear makeup.
Glycerin
A humectant that draws moisture to the skin to prevent the product from drying out or cracking. It is safe and commonly used in skincare.
Propylene Glycol
Functions as a solvent and humectant to improve the texture and spreadability of the eyeliner. It is generally recognized as safe for topical cosmetic use.
Phenoxyethanol
A preservative used to prevent the growth of bacteria and fungi in the product. It is a common alternative to parabens, though some individuals may have sensitivities.
How it scores against your goal
Mood Effect
The aesthetic appeal and high-shine finish can provide a positive boost to user self-confidence.
Pcos Management
The formula avoids known endocrine-disrupting parabens, making it a relatively safe choice for hormonal health.
Myth busters
Contains real crushed gemstone mica
This product uses Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, not natural mica.
Contains hydrating agents
Contains Glycerin, a humectant that draws moisture to the skin.
Packaging is eco-friendly
The plastic components are difficult to recycle due to their small size.
Frequently asked questions
Is GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner safe to use?
+
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner is considered safe for topical cosmetic use by most consumers, though individuals with specific chemical sensitivities should perform a patch test first.
What is the main concern with GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner?
+
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner contains synthetic polymers and preservatives that, while functional for makeup longevity, do not provide any skin-nourishing benefits.
What is the key ingredient in GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner?
+
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner utilizes Synthetic Fluorphlogopite as its primary ingredient to create a consistent, high-impact metallic sparkle effect.
Is GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner vegan-friendly?
+
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner uses synthetic components rather than animal-derived ingredients, making the formula generally compatible with vegan beauty standards.
Are there better alternatives to GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner?
+
GIVE ME MORE... SHINE! Metallic Eyeliner can be replaced by natural mineral-based eyeliners if you prefer to avoid synthetic polymers like acrylates copolymer.